I bought a shock collar three years ago.
It sat in my closet unused until three weeks ago.
Why did an enlightened, educated, dog-loving person like myself by a “horrible device” like a shock collar?
It was fear!
Ludwig is a black Miniature Schnauzer we adopted from the shelter five years ago to be our then-seven-year-old daughter’s companion.
Back in my old days of pure off-leash walks, Ludwig had a problem with chasing deer. Ludwig’s terrier love of hunting drove his habit of ranging several hundred feet in front of me when we’d hike, and then I wouldn’t see him around a corner – suddenly I’d hear his excited “ON THE TRAIL” yipping slanting up the hillside. He was utterly unable to respond to my calls to come, even though in normal situations he had a wonderful “come-when-called” response. One horrible day, he took off and when I heard that yipping, I realized my very obedient young Lab mix “Levi” had run with him. Levi never had any interest in deer, but he couldn’t resist Ludwig’s enthusiasm. Both of them were too focused and too far to hear my calls by the time I realized what had happened. They were gone for four hours…the horror of thinking I’d lost two beloved family members in one day pushed me to buy the “e-collar”.
I’d trained Ludwig to “Come”, like all my other dogs, but his response was utterly uncontrollable when he was hot on a deer trail. Miraculously, when I started “leadership walking” with my dogs, he quit looking for deer. I believe he felt more connected to the “pack”, and wasn’t constantly searching for deer trails – he was content to hang out with me and the other dogs during our off-leash play time.
Unfortunately, Ludwig had another problem area that proved impossible for me to solve with my normal training: When he spotted a dog approaching or walking by, he would run to it utterly heedless of my calling him. Although his deer-chasing behavior was scary and frustrating, this dog-rushing behavior was dangerous! Ludwig is only 15 pounds, and seems utterly clueless to dog signals of aggression. He has had a couple of close calls with large, vicious dogs over the years because I could not call him back to me when he got focused.
I never did use the collar for deer-chasing, but a few weeks ago, after Ludwig ran after dogs yet again – nice dogs, fortunately – I knew it was time to try the e-collar. I brought it out, read the materials, watched the video and made my game plan. It went like this:
1. Put the collar on when we get ready to get into the car, to connect the collar with the happy moment of going for a walk.
2. Sound the reward tone and pair with a tidbit of cheese or meat, so I can pair the collar with reward both close and at a distance, for the first week.
3. Condition him to run immediately to me when he feels a correction “nick” from the collar, so he doesn’t panic and feel confused.
4. Start with easy distractions first, like a bit of old garbage, or a spot he rolled in last week. Sequence: “Ludwig Here! [he ignores -“nick”-] Ludwig here!” Reward when he arrives.
5. Use the “nick” correction just like a leash correction.
6. Continue to practice on low-level distractions: kids running down road, or the neighbor in her driveway.
7. Expose him to dogs we know as distractions –dogs we know are safe, in case we fail.
8. Finally, practice and be ready for the real thing: when we’re playing off-leash and a strange dog shows up somewhere in Ludwig’s line of vision.
We have made it through step 8 now, and I’m delighted to feel like I have conquered this five-year-long problem finally! I am very, very happy with this tool. Now, for the things that scare me about the e-collar:
1. It is far to easy to hurt and/or scare your dog. With the level of ignorance, impatience and/or anger I have seen in the majority of the pet dog-owning population, it really frightens me to think of the average pet owner with this tool. Because of the ease of pushing a button, it’s very tempting to push it, “just in case”, or to get the level wrong accidentally and really freak the dog out, or to use excessive corrections out of anger, or to not have the right timing and correct the dog at the wrong moment, or not stop correction at the right moment. It’s a very precision instrument. Of course, people can scare and hurt their dogs in a lot of other ways too…it’s just too easy with the e-collar.
2. Unless the dog really, REALLY knows the command, (here’s a good article on training the come command), correcting him for not obeying it is terribly unfair and damaging to his trust in you. In some instances, shocking a dog who is far away, and hasn’t been trained with rewards and consistency what correct behavior to execute when he feels the shock, can result in strange phobias in the dog. (Fear of trucks, because he was standing near one when he got “magically” nicked, for instance!)
3. Using the e-collar when the owner isn’t knowledgeable enough to know the true cause of the dog’s behavior can cause some nasty consequences. For example, sometimes people want to solve “aggression” with an e-collar. They don’t know why their dog is aggressive, they just want it to stop. Aggression has many, many causes, and needs a more intelligent solution that gets into the dog’s psyche to unravel the puzzle. An e-collar is a very simple tool, like a leash that you “pop” to give a negative stimulus. When you push that button, you had better be very, very sure that you know what or whom the dog is going to blame the punishment on. If he’s staring down the neighbor’s Shepherd, you don’t want him thinking it was the Shepherd who just nipped his neck!
4. On my model, the hand-held unit doesn’t have a constant reading of what level you’re on – I have to push a button to see it. I constantly check it so I know it’s at the right setting. I nicked Ludwig at a too-high setting once, and he jumped completely off of the ground. On the other hand, if he suddenly takes off at high speed, I need a higher setting than normal fast, and to waste time checking the level when he’s moving into danger at high speed isn’t a good thing.
With a dog who has problems listening at a distance, the e-collar can be a lifesaver. I’m kicking myself for not using this tool earlier with Ludwig. I cannot emphasize enough how crucial proper pre-training is though. Read the manual, watch the DVD the tool comes with, and/or contact a professional for help!
4 thoughts on “Shocking Information”
Danelle, great blog!! Now my question. I really have a problem with the girls taking off when they see people or dogs AND not listening to the recall. Now they have started chasing 4-wheelers and cars that past by the house. With training would this be a tool that would work with them??
Oh, and your mother says hello 🙂
Hi! Yes, definitely, an e-collar would be great.
If you’re talking about them taking off from your yard though, you might look into the new electric fences. They’re all wireless now, so they’re ridiculously easy to set up, and I’ve heard many clients swear by them. I’d use that for multiple dogs who are dashing from the yard.
If you want off-leash control when you’re out on walks, or when you’re hanging out in the yard with the dogs, then the e-collar is great. They all come with training info, and step-by-step instructions to strengthen and clarify the dogs’ responses to whatever command you’re teaching. You can use the e-collar just like a leash, “popping” them with the shock just like you’d do a leash. I haven’t tried multiple dogs like this though. I know there are collars that have several channels to work multiple dogs, but I think those are pretty expensive.
Another way I’ve used the e-collar with Ludwig is when we’re in the car and he barks. I cannot reach him to correct him, but a very quick nick and “quiet” seems to work well. It works like the Cesar “touch” on the dog’s side to “snap the dog out of their excited state” – the shock stops them for just a second so you can access their brain which was crazy-focused on being excited about something else.
What brand would you recommend?
Hi Judy, I really like the Dogtra-IQ. Thanks for reading!